After divorcing Ross Wesley LeBaron in 1948, Thelma Elena Cox LeBaron made some headlines looking for a new husband. “Mrs. LeBaron would like to get a new husband to help support the home and her children so she can find some time to paint”, stated a front page report in the Salt Lake Telegram, in April, 1949. Her main concern was the scarcity of money and food. “Attractive Divorcee Seeks S[alt] L[ake] Husband” was the title.
According to a news article from the United Press, published a few days later in an Austin newspaper, plural marriage, money and conflict of personalities were pointed by Thelma Cox and her ex-husband as causes for the separation.
Before their separation, the LeBarons had had a baby boy the previous December.
Elena LeBaron, as she is referred to by the article, is again praised by her looks — “pretty” is the very first word of the article, and four paragraphs later she is described as a “shapely brunette”. The photograph of the divorced mother and her eight children occupies a larger part of the page than the text itself.
This time, the name of Ross LeBaron is mentioned. He is portraited as a “prophet for polygamy” and “self-styled ‘prophet” convicted during the 1944 trails of polygamist Mormons and a former inmate during the year of 1941, convicted of marrying a 14-year-old as his plural wife.
Less than ten days after the initial piece in the Salt Lake Telegram, another report shows a suitor who flew from Hawaii to Utah to meet Thelma. In the best tabloid style, artist Cedric Younger Von Rolleston is described as a “frightened little man with sad eyes”. (Interestingly, the painter used an alias and lied about being Dutch).
Despite Thelma Elena Cox’s mention of polygamy as a cause for divorcing LeBaron, the following July she would married another man involved with the Fundamentalist movement.
Robert Leslie Shrewsbury was one of the men charged of “conspiracy” during the federal and multi-state operation against Mormon polygamists in 1944, along with Thelma’s ex-husband. The coincidence was not detected by the journalists at the time.
Shrewsbury was also a divorcee, and father of four. In 1948, his wife Margaret had filed for divorce on the grounds of “mental cruelty”.
The marriage between Thelma Elena and Robert Shrewsbury only lasted for about four months. “Husbands are an overrated institution”, she was reported saying in an article syndicated by a New York newspaper. Shrewsbury, allegedly, had “failed to provide the financial security” she needed.
After that, Ross and Thelma reunited one more time. They would separate again around 1950.
The couple had first met in 1936-37, when Ross LeBaron went to Short Creek, in the Arizona Strip, to work with John Y. Barlow. Thelma then lived with her parents in Cane Beds, a few miles east of the polygamous community.